I was really hoping to enjoy this book. Considering the books I normally read, this seemed a perfect fit to me. Unfortunately, it falls a little short of my expectations for a good urban-fantasy read. I don't expect great literature, but I do want believable characters, fast-paced action, and scary monsters.
I couldn't relate to the protagonist, Elizabeth Phoenix, a psychic ex-cop turned bartender. I also didn't care about the relationship between her and her childhood love, Jimmy Sarducci. (I will not be going into my problems with the names.) I know he is supposed to be the "bad boy" type, but really, he's just not like-able and I couldn't understand or believe the attraction.
The mystery starts off right at the beginning when Elizabeth's friend and former guardian is found murdered. She discovers that Ruthie was a "seer" that helped demon killers find their prey and somehow passed her gifts on to Liz. The middle was a little slow while Elizabeth comes to grips with her newfound knowledge and gifts. The action picks back up towards the end, but in a very different way than I was expecting. The book went from urban-fantasy to racy romance book and not in a good way. The amount of sex going on for what seems like the entire last 1/4 of the book is not romantic, just disturbing and doesn't help in making me like or respect Phoenix as a female character I want to read about.
The monsters were somewhat interesting and different from the usual batch of supernaturals that fill the fantasy books I love. They are very obscure, however, so I felt the need to research a bit. Not something I really want to do while reading this type of book.
I think if the "romance" plot line was left out or if Elizabeth was given a better way to absorb others powers this would have made for a much better read. It was good enough to keep me reading to the end but there are definitely much better urban-fantasy books with much stronger more likable women protagonists.
2/5
You can see Blacklin's review of Any Given Doomsday on her blog, Blacklin's Reading Room Reviews & More.
Hi! Here's the link to my post: http://blacklinsreadingroomreviewsandmore.com/2008/09/22/arc-any-given-doomsday/
ReplyDeleteThanks!
I don't normally read these types of books, but I requested it anyway. I think it's good to try new things. I haven't heard great things about it so far, but I'll give it a try anyway.
ReplyDelete--Anna
http://diaryofaneccentric.blogspot.com
Interesting review. I do agree with you on alot of it. I'm nearly done with it myself, hope to post my review up soon.
ReplyDeleteI don't like Sanducci or Sawyer. They both just seem like jerks to me.
http://thebookworm07.blogspot.com/
Great review! I am definitely glad I stopped reading when I did. Thanks for stopping by my blog by the way :)
ReplyDelete